Fragmented Property Rights and Residents’ Participation in Renovation of Old Communities: Comparative Case Studies in Haikou, China
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.4335/20.1.259-277(2022)Keywords:
renovation of old communities, resident's participation, fragmented property rights, resident's committee, homeowners' associationAbstract
Insufficient residents’ participation in the renovation of old communities is ubiquitous in urban China. This paper attempts to explain the reasons for this phenomenon. Based on the theory of anti-commons, this research intends to explore how the fragmentation of property rights impedes residents’ participation, and then unravel the mechanism of conflicts and cooperation among various stakeholders in renovation projects. Abundant qualitative data in terms of the situation of property rights were collected by semi-structured interviews from fieldwork on seven renovation projects in Haikou, Hainan Province, China. Then we compared the seven projects to examine the relationship between property rights and resident’s participation. This study shows that characteristics of residents’ participation vary from types of property rights in the renovation of old communities. Residents’ participation can be facilitated by the privatization of property rights, but fragmented property rights tend to impede participation. Meanwhile, administrative obstacles between street offices, residents’ committees, and homeowners’ associations will ebb residents’ motivation for participation. Yet the homeowners’ association plays an important role in dispute handling, which can promote residents’ involvement.
References
Aitken, D. (2017) The influence fallacy: resident motivations for participation in an English housing regeneration project, Planning Theory & Practice, 18(4), pp.549-565.
Barzel, Y. (1997) Economic analysis of property rights (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Coase, R. H. (1960) The problem of social cost. In Classic papers in natural resource economics (London: Palgrave Macmillan)
Coase, R.H. (1988) The Firm, the Market and the Law (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).
Cox, K.R. (1982) Housing tenure and neighborhood activism, Urban Affairs Quarterly, 18(1), pp.107-129.
Chen, P. (2013) A study on owners committee in state-market-society perspective: based on the community ethnographic investigation in B City, Journal of Public Management, 10(3), pp.75-89. (in Chinese)
Chen, W. D. & Xu, B. J. (2016) Dislocation of community governance responsibility and governance ability and its solution — based on survey of 12 communities in Hubei Province, Journal of Huazhong Agricultural University (Social Sciences Edition), 1, pp.101-107. (in Chinese)
Cho, M. & Kim, J. (2016) Coupling urban regeneration with age-friendliness: neighborhood regeneration in Jangsu Village, Seoul, Cities, 58, pp. 107-114.
Cai, Y. N., Yang, X. & Li, D. (2017) Micro-transformation’: the renewal method of old urban community, Urban Development Studies, 24 (4), pp.29-34. (in Chinese)
Chen, J.G. (2017) The situation and influential factors of participation in urban community governance —an empirical analysis of questionnaire survey in Beijing, Journal of Tianjin Administration Institute, 19 (1), pp.11-18. (in Chinese)
Dietz, R. D. & Haurin, D. R. (2003) The social and private micro-level consequences of homeownership, Journal of urban Economics, 54(3), pp.401-450.
Deng, D.C. (2014) Relevant interests: the driving force of effectively realizing the residents' autonomy, Southeast Academic Research, 5, pp. 40-49. (in Chinese)
Ghimire, R. (2020) Homeownership and Community Involvement: Results From the 2019 Metro Atlanta Speaks Survey, Housing Policy Debate, 31(6), pp.1-25.
Hu, R. (2006) Social capital and villagers’ local autonomous participation in rural China: an analysis of factors influencing villagers’ participation in village elections, Sociological Studies, 2, pp. 61-85. (in Chinese)
Hu, R. (2008) Social capital and political participation of urban residents, Sociological Studies, 5, pp. 142-159. (in Chinese)
Heller M. (1998), The tragedy of the anticommons: property in the transition from Marx to markets, Harvard law review, 111(3), pp.621-688.
He, S. (2015) Homeowner associations and neighborhood governance in Guangzhou, China, Eurasian Geography and Economics, 56(3), pp. 260-284.
Kintrea, K. (1996) Whose partnership? Community interests in the regeneration of a Scottish housing scheme, Housing studies, 11(2), pp. 287-306.
Kollock, P. (1998) Social dilemmas: The anatomy of cooperation, Annual review of sociology, 24(1), pp. 183-214.
Li, H.L. (1993) The unit phenomenon and the integration mechanism of urban community in China, Sociological Studies, 5, pp.23-32. (in Chinese)
Li, H.L. & Li, L.L. (1999) Resources and exchange — the dependency structure in the Chinese organization, Sociological Studies, 4, pp. 46-65. (in Chinese)
Li, J. (2009) Home ownership and political activism: democratizing neighborhood in urban China, Sociological Studies,5, pp.57-82. (in Chinese)
Li, Y.M. et al. (2012) The ‘publicity’ dilemma in the social construction of contemporary China and how it can be transcended, Social Sciences in China, 4, pp.125-139. (in Chinese)
Liang, C. Z. & Li, C. (2016) Main methods and considerations for the comprehensive renovation of old communities in Beijing, Construction Science and Technology, 9, pp. 20-23. (in Chinese)
Gu, T., Li, D., Zhang, M. & Jiang, Y. (2019) Research on the influencing factors of residents’ participation in old community renewal: a case study of Nanjing, Construction Economy, 40(3), pp. 93-99. (in Chinese)
Li, H. J. & Hu, J. C. (2019) Research on the community classification governance in China, Macroeconomics, 11, pp. 143-157. (in Chinese)
Luan, X. F. & Tao, R. (2019) Beyond ‘predicament of anti-commons’: mechanism design and planning response in urban renewal, City Planning Review, 43(10), pp. 47-42. (in Chinese)
Li, J. X., Shan, S. & Wang, P. (2020) Study on the organic renewal countermeasures of the old urban area, Shanghai Urban Management,4, pp.80-85. (in Chinese)
Ma, X. H. (2004) Residential participation in the framework of community governance: a reflective exploration, The Journal of Shanghai Administration Institute, 5(2), pp. 59-67. (in Chinese)
McCabe, B. J. (2013) Are homeowners better citizens? Homeownership and community participation in the United States, Social Forces, 91(3), pp. 929-954.
Olson, M. (1989) “Collective action”, In: Eatwell J., Milgate M. & Newman P. (eds) The Invisible Hand (London: Palgrave Macmillan), pp. 61-69.
Qian, X. Cai, Y. & Yin, C. (2019) Driving Force of Grassroots Self-governance in Beijing's Neighborhoods: Social Capital, Community Network and Community Service Motivation, Lex Localis – Journal of Local Self-Government, 17(1), pp.159-177.
Qian, X. & Yin, C. (2018) From Redevelopment to Gentrification in Hong Kong: A Case Study of Kwun Tong Town Center Project, Open House International, 43(3), pp. 83-93.
Qian, X. Chen, Y. & Cheung, E. S. L. (2019) Changes and Trend of Public Housing Policy in Netherlands, Hong Kong and Mainland China, In: 2019 International Conference on Pedagogy, Communication and Sociology, pp. 428-433 (Dordercht: Atlantis Press).
Rohe, W. M. & Stegman, M. A. (1994) The impact of home ownership on the social and political involvement of low-income people, Urban Affairs Quarterly, 30(1), pp. 152-172.
Rohe, W. M. & Stewart, L. S. (1996) Homeownership and neighborhood stability, Housing policy debate, 7(1), pp. 37-81.
Rossi, P. H. & Weber, E. (1996) The social benefits of homeownership: empirical evidence from national surveys, Housing policy debate,7(1), pp. 1-35.
Sa, H., & Haila, A. (2021) Urban villagers as real estate developers: embracing property mind through ‘planting’housing in North-east China, Housing Studies, pp. 1-21.
Saunders, P. & Harris, C. (1990) Privatization and the consumer, Sociology,24(1), pp. 57-75.
Sun, L.P. (2001) Community, Social Capital and Community Education, Academia Bimestrial, 4, pp. 93-96. (in Chinese)
Sun, L. (2006) Interests, Identification and System Arrangement: An Analysis on Influential Factors in Participation of Urbanite's Community, Social Sciences in Yunnan, 5, pp,70-73. (in Chinese)
Sun, B. Y. (2016) How is the debureaucratization of the urban community residents’ committee possible?, Nanjing Journal of Social Sciences, 7, pp. 51-58. (in Chinese)
Saunders, P. (2021) A nation of home owners (London: Routledge).
Tang, Y. C. & Hu, B. (2016) Public participation in community governance: national identity and community identity as two driving forces, Journal of Yunnan Normal University (Humanities and Social Sciences Edition),48(2), pp.63-69. (in Chinese)
Van der Merwe, C. G. (1996) The comparative law of apartment ownership, Scottish Law and Practice Quarterly, 1(3), pp. 205-216.
Verberg, N. (2000) Homeownership and politics: testing the political incorporation thesis, Canadian Journal of Sociology, 25(2), pp. 169-195.
Wu, Z.Z. (2001) The ‘Danwei’ Capital and Social Stratification, Zhejiang Social Sciences, 5, pp. 93-96. (in Chinese)
Wang, X. Z. & Feng, T. (2004) Urban residents’ participation willingness to community: based on the questionnaire survey in H City, Zhejiang Social Sciences, 4, pp. 97-103. (in Chinese)
Wang, Z. Z. (2010) A comparative study of governance models for urban renewal, Urban Insight, 3, pp. 123-130. (in Chinese)
Wu, G. C. (2013) Research on ownership structure of old community, China Real Estate, 22, pp. 56-61. (in Chinese)
Wu, Y., Galdini, R., Hui, E. C. M. & Long, H. (2020) Urban regeneration and re-use: China and Europe, Cities,106, pp. 1.
Yin, C. & Qian, X. (2020) The spatial production of simulacrascape in urban China: Economic function, local identity and cultural authenticity, Cities, 104, 102806.
Yang, A. P. & Yu, Y. H. (2012) Selective pressurizing-responding: an organizational study of the behavior logic of the community residents’ committee, Sociological Studies, 27(4), pp. 105-126. (in Chinese)
Yang, X. W. & Yang, C. X. (2019) A comparative study of the tragedy of the commons and the tragedy of the anti-commons, Zhejiang Social Sciences, 3, pp. 4-13. (in Chinese)
Yip, N.M. (2019) Housing activism in urban China: the quest for autonomy in neighbourhood governance, Housing Studies, 34(10), pp. 1635-1653.
Yip, N.M. (2020) Urban activism in confined civil spaces: Networked organizations of housing activists in urban China, Journal of urban affairs, 42(2), pp. 222-240.
Zhang, B.F. (2005) On the cause of motivation lack of rural community participation, Henan Social Sciences, 4, pp. 22-25. (in Chinese)
