Constitutional Duties and Decisionism in the Context of Constitutional Control Bodies' Implementation of their Political Functions: Systemic and Organizational Aspects

  • Nikolay Antsiferov Рeoples’ Friendship University of Russia (RUDN University), Department of Constitutional Law and Constitutional Proceedings
  • Eduard Galitsky Рeoples’ Friendship University of Russia (RUDN University), Department of Constitutional Law and Constitutional Proceedings
  • Ruslan Chermit Рeoples’ Friendship University of Russia (RUDN University), Department of Constitutional Law and Constitutional Proceedings
Keywords: constitutional dispute, constitutional duties, decisionism, constitutionalism, judicial procedure

Abstract

The purpose of this study is to examine the role of constitutional control in the framework of state lawmaking and law enforcement functions and the impact of constitutional control bodies on political development, economic transformation, and social policy. This study examines the role and place of constitutional control in the state legal mechanism, the advantages and disadvantages of specialized and non-specialized constitutional control, preventive constitutional control. The study concludes that the model of non-specialized centralized constitutional control is very promising, capable of effectively balancing the logic of decisionism (discretion) and the scope of constitutional responsibilities. This study examines the relationship between the constitutional control and decisionism from the point of view of the Russian legal system. In practical terms, this study is of interest to representatives of the legal profession, practicing in the field of human rights protection, human rights organizations, and members of the judiciary.

References

Alter, K. J. (2018) National Perspectives on International Constitutional Review: Diverging Optics, In: Delaney, E. F. & Dixon, R. (eds.) Comparative Judicial Review (Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing), pp. 244–271.

Ampleeva, T. Y. & Karaulova, J. A. (2017) Constitutional control in Russia: Issues of evolvement, theory and practice. Constitutional Control in Russia: issues of evolvement, theory and practice, Giornale di storia costituzionale, 33(1), pp. 81-95.

Andreeva, Y. A., Balytnikov V. V. & Bondar N. S. (2012) Commentary on the Federal Constitutional Law "On the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation" (itemized) (Moscow: Norma, Infra).

Antonov, A. V. (2015a) Constitutional Council of France: Formation Procedure and Reform Projects, Comparative Constitutional Review, 6, pp. 88-105.

Antonov, A. V. (2015b) Reform of the Constitutional Council of France. Constitutional Council of France at the Present Stage: A collection of articles (Moscow: Publishing group "Lawyer").

Aranovsky, K. V. & Knyazev, S. D. (2013) The Fate of the Judicial Precedent in Romano-Germanic Law, Journal of Constitutional Justice, 4, pp. 30-39.

Barak, A. (2009) The Judge in a Democracy (Princeton: Princeton University Press).

Barak, A. (2012) Proportionality: constitutional rights and their limitations (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).

Bondar, N. S. (2011) Judicial Constitutionalism in Russia in the Light of Constitutional Justice (Moscow: Infra).

Bondar, N. S. & Dzhagaryan, A. A. (2018) Justice: An Orientation towards the Constitution: A Monograph (Moscow: NORMA, INFRA).

Brewer-Carias, A. (2010) Constitutional Courts as Positive Legislators in Comparative Law, In: General Report on XVIII International Congress of Comparative Law, Washington, pp. 1-22.

Buchanan, A. (2018) Institutional legitimacy, Oxford Studies in Political Philosophy, 4, pp. 53-80.

Casper, G. (1987) Constitutionalism, University of Chicago Law Occasional Paper, 22, pp. 3-20.

Chirkin, B. E. (2004) Public Administration. Textbook (Moscow: Yurist).

Chirkin, B. E. (2013) Constitutional Terminology (Moscow: Norma).

Comella, V. F. (2003) The consequences of centralizing constitutional review in a special court: some thoughts on judicial activism, Texas Law Review, 82, pp. 1705-109.

Dani, M. (2017) National constitutional courts in the European constitutional democracy: A reply to Jan Komárek, International Journal of Constitutional Law, 15(3), pp. 785-800.

De Visser, M. (2013) Constitutional Review in Europe: A Comparative Analysis (London: Bloomsbury Publishing).

Determann, L. & Heintzen, M. (2018) Constitutional Review of Statutes in Germany and the United States Compared, Journal of Transnational Law & Policy, 28, pp. 95-117.

Ducat, C. R. (2012) Constitutional Interpretation: Powers of Government, Volume 1 (Cengage Learning).

Eremyan, V. V. (2017) Constitutional (State) Law of Foreign Countries: A Textbook for University Students Studying Jurisprudence (Moscow: UNITY-DANA).

European Commission for Democracy through Law (2020) Compilation of Venice Commission Opinions, Reports and Studies on Constitutional Justice, available at: https://www.venice.coe.int/webforms/documents/?pdf=CDL-PI(2020)004-e (September 1, 2021).

Gadzhiev, G. (1999) Legal positions of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation as a source of constitutional law, Constitutional Law: Eastern European Review, 3, pp. 81-85.

Garoupa, N. (2017) Constitutional Review. Volume 2, In: Congleton, R. D., Grofman, B., & Voigt, S. (eds) The Oxford handbook of public choice (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

Halberstam, D. (2019) How Europe Brought Judicial Review to France: A Response to Bruce Ackerman. Revolutionary Constitutionalism (Oxford, Hart: University of Michigan Public Law Research Paper).

Hein, M. (2020) Do Constitutional Entrenchment Clauses Matter? Constitutional Review of Constitutional Amendments in Europe, International Journal of Constitutional Law, 18(1), pp. 78-110.

Ivanov, A. A. (2017) Seventh Instance? Bulletin of Economic Justice of the Russian Federation, 4, pp. 86-92.

Karapetov, A. G. (2011) Struggle for the Recognition of Judicial Lawmaking in European and American Law (Moscow: Statut).

Kelemen, K. (2017) Judicial dissent in European constitutional courts: A Comparative and Legal Perspective (New York: Routledge).

Kelsen, H. (1942) Judicial Review of Legislation: A Comparative Study of the Austrian and the American Constitution, The Journal of Politics, 4(2), pp. 183-200.

Kelsen, H. (2015) Pure Doctrine of Law. 2nd ed. (SPb.: Publishing House Alef-Press).

Klishas, A. A. (2006) The principle of separation of powers as a conceptual basis for the institutionalization of the system of constitutional control and constitutional justice, Bulletin of the St. Petersburg University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, 4, pp. 136-137.

Klishas, A. A. (2016) Public Law of the Countries of Latin America: In 2 volumes. V. 2. Formation and Development of Institutions of Constitutional Control (Moscow: International Relations).

Kokotova, M. A. (2014) Council of State of France as a Body of Constitutional Control, Actual Problems of Russian Law, 6, pp. 1084-1089.

Kokotova, M. A. (2015) Realization of Procedural Rights of Citizens in the Activities of Constitutional Control Bodies: Experience of Russia and France. In The Constitutional Council of France at the present stage. Five Years of the Priority Question of Constitutionality (Moscow: Lawyer), pp. 119-130.

Kombos, C. (2019) Constitutional Review and the Economic Crisis: In the Courts We Trust?, European Public Law, 25(1), pp. 105-133.

Kyritsis, D. (2017) Where Our Protection Lies: Separation of Powers and Constitutional Review (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

Malyutin, N. S. (2017) Reaction of the Constitutional Court of the Russian Federation to Non-Execution of its Own Decisions, Constitutional and Municipal Law, 1, pp. 55-61.

Mazák, J. (2006) The European model of constitutional review of legislation, available at: https://www.venice.coe.int/SACJF/2006_02_Venice_Strasbourg/report_mazak.htm (September 1, 2021).

Menéndez, A. J. (2017) Constitutional Review, Luxembourg Style: A Structural Critique of the Way in which the European Court of Justice Reviews the Constitutionality of the Laws of the Member States of the European Union, Contemporary Readings in Law and Social Justice, 9(2), pp. 116-145.

Narutto, S. V. (2015) On the Issue of Legal Certainty of Legislation, Actual Problems of Russian Law, 11, pp. 9-19.

Neudorfer, S. & Wernig, C. (2010) Implementation of International treaties into national legal orders: The protection of the rights of the child within the Austrian legal system, In: Max Planck Yearbook of United Nations Law (Netherlands: Martinus Nijhoff Publishers), pp. 409-444.

Orlov, A. G. (2001) The highest authorities of the countries of Latin America (Moscow: Publishing house "Ankil").

Paris, M. L. (2017) The French Constitutional Council: Another ‘Work-in-Progress’. UCD Working Papers in Law, Criminology & Socio-Legal Studies Research Paper No. 15/17 (University College Dublin).

Provine, D. M. & Garapon, A. (2018) 9. The selection of judges in France: Searching for a new legitimacy, In: Appointing Judges in an Age of Judicial Power (Toronto: University of Toronto Press), pp. 176-195.

Rosenfeld, M. (2018) US Constitutional Review: Antimajoritarian but Democratic?, Journal of Constitutional Justice, 1, p. 561.

Schroeder, P. A. (2018) The political dynamics of constitutional review, available at: https://phischroeder.github.io/assets/PhilippSchroeder_APSA2018_final.pdf (September 1, 2021).

Shustrov, D. (2017) Essentia Constitutionis: The Constitution of the Russian Federation in the Focus of Theories of the Constitution of the XX-XXI Centuries, Comparative Constitutional Review, 4, pp. 78-93.

Steinberger, H. (1994) Structural Elements of Western European Constitutional Jurisdiction, In: Modern German constitutionalism (Moscow: Institute of State and Law), pp. 24-31.

Stone Sweet, A. (2007) The Politics of Constitutional Review in France and Europe, International Journal of Constitutional Law, 5, pp. 69-92.

Stone Sweet, A. (2011) Constitutional courts, In: The Oxford Handbook of Comparative Constitutional Law (Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press), pp. 816-830.

Tiede, L. B. (2020) Mixed Judicial Selection and Constitutional Review, Comparative Political Studies, 53(7), pp. 1092-1123.

Volcansek, M. L. (1992) Judges, courts and policy‐making in Western Europe, West European Politics, 15(3), pp. 1-8.

Zelentsov, A. B. (2012) Subjective Public Law (Moscow: Peoples' Friendship University of Russia).

Published
2022-04-21
Section
Article