The Flypaper Effect and Desirable Legislative Changes to Local Government Financing Systems
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.4335/19.3.587-608(2021)Keywords:
flypaper effect, local finance, grants, local expenditure, fiscal illusionAbstract
A substantial portion of local government funding in Poland comes from intergovernmental transfers. It may lead to the flypaper effect, which means that external revenues contribute to greater local government spending than locally-collected revenues. This study analyses how different revenue categories influenced local government spending in Poland between 2009 and 2018. Panel econometric models are used to test a hypothesis about whether the flypaper effect occurred in that period and to identify the potential causes. The results confirm to some extent that all three levels of local government were affected by the flypaper effect, and they point to intergovernmental transfers (general grants, specific grants, and shares of corporate income tax revenue) as the main causes. The research findings can be of use in reforming local government funding legislation in Poland and other countries, especially when the size of the public sector and public spending need to be reduced.
References
Allers, M.A. & Vermeulen, W. (2016) Capitalization of equalizing grants and the flypaper effect, Regional Science and Urban Economics 58, pp. 115–129, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.regsciurbeco.2016.03.005.
Aragón, F. M. (2010) The Flypaper Effect and Costly Tax Collection, available at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/228705968_The_Flypaper_Effect_and_Costly_Tax_Collection, (February 10, 2020)
Aronson, J. R. & Munley, V. G. (1996) (Non)equivalence in a federalism: Dual tax shares, flypaper effects and Leviathan, Public Choice, 89, pp. 53–62, https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00114278.
Bae S.-S. & Feiock R. (2006) The Flypaper Effect Revisited: Intergovernmental Grants and Local Governance, International Journal of Public Administration, 27(8-9), pp. 577-596.
Baekgaard, M. &. Kjaergaard, M. (2016) Intergovernmental Grants and Public Expenditures: Evidence from a Survey Experiment, Local Government Studies, 42 (2), pp. 189-207.
Baltagi, B.H (2005) Econometric Analysis of Panel Data (Hoboken: John Wiley and Sons Ltd.)
Barnett, R., Levaggi, R. & Smith, P. (1991) Does the Flypaper Model Stick? A Test of the Relative Performance of the Flypaper and Conventional Models of Local Government Budgetary Behaviour, Public Choice, 69(1), pp. 1-18, available at: http://www.jstor.org/stable/30025394 (November 2, 2020).
S.J. & Connolly S. (1998) The flypaper effect: Identifying areas for further research, Public Choice, 95, pp. 335–361.
Becker E. (1996) The illusion of fiscal illusion: Unsticking the flypaper effect, Public Choice, 86, pp. 85-102.
Boadway, R. & Shah, A. (2009) Fiscal Federalism. Principles and Practice of Multiorder Governance (New York: Cambridge University Press).
Bradford, D. & Oates, W. (1971) Towards a Predictive Theory of Intergovernmental Grants, American Economic Review, 61, p. 440.
Brennan, G. & Pincus, J. J. (1996) A Minimalist Model of Federal Grants and Flypaper Effects, Journal of Public Economics, 61(2), pp. 229-246.
Cameron, A. C. & Trivedi, P. K. (2009) Microeconometrics. Methods and Applications (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
Campbell R. J. (2004) Leviathan and Fiscal Illusion in Local Government Overlapping Jurisdictions, Public Choice, 120(3-4), pp. 301-329.
Chalil, T. M. (2018) The Size of Flypaper Effect in Decentralizing Indonesia, MPRA Paper No. 98358, available at: https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/98358/ (February 3, 2020).
Chiades, P., Grecob, L., Mengotto, V., Moretti, V. & Valbonesi, P. (2019) Fiscal consolidation by intergovernmental transfers cuts? The unpleasant effect on expenditure arrears, Economic Modelling 77, available at: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.econmod.2018.09.008 (February 3, 2020).
Cottrell, A. & Lucchetti, R. (2018) Gretl User’s Guide, Gnu Regression, Econometrics and Time-series Library, available at: http://gretl.sourceforge.net/gretl-help/gretl-guide.pdf (June 20, 2020).
Dell’Anno, R. & Dollery, B. (2012) Comparative fiscal illusion: A fiscal illusion index for the European Union, Munich Personal RePEc Archive, MPRA Paper No. 42537, pp. 1-30, available at: https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/42537/ (February 11, 2020).
Dollery, B. & Worthington, A. (1996) The Empirical Analysis of Fiscal Illusion, Journal of Economic Surveys 10(3), pp. 261-297.
Działo, J., Guziejewska, B., Majdzińska, & A., Żółtaszek, A. (2019) Determinants of Local Government Deficit and Debt: Evidence from Polish Municipalities, Lex localis - Journal of Local Self-Government, 17(4), pp. 1033 – 1056.
Eurostat, Nomenclature of territorial units for statistics, available at: https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/nuts/background and https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/nuts/local-administrative-units (July 22, 2020).
Due J. F. (1963) Government Finance. An Economic Analysis, Homewood (Illinois: Richard D. Irwin Inc.).
Gamkhar, S. & Oates,W. (1996) Asymmetries in the response to increases and decreases in intergovernmental grants: Some empirical findings. National Tax Journal, 49, pp. 501–511.
Goeminne, S., Smolders, C. & Vandrope, E. (2017) The real impact of a one-off fiscal restriction: empirical evidence of a flypaper effect in Flemish municipalities, Public Money & Management, 37(4), pp. 285-292.
Gordon, N. (2004) Do Federal Grants Boots School Spending? Evidence from Title I, Journal of Public Economics, 88, pp. 1771-1792.
Gramlich, E. M. & Galper, H. (1973) State and local fiscal behaviour and federal grant policy, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity 1, pp. 15–58, available at: https://www.brookings.edu/wp- content/uploads/1973/01/1973a_bpea_gramlich_galper_goldfeld_mcguire.pdf (February 10, 2020).
Gramlich, E. M. (1977) Intergovernmental grants: A review of the empirical literature, In: W.E. Oates (ed.) The political economy of fiscal federalism (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press) pp. 219-239.
Guziejewska, B. (2015) Designing a revenue structure in local self-government entities in Poland: taxes versus grants, Equilibrium. Quarterly Journal of Economics and Economic Policy, 10(3), https://doi.org/10.12775/EQUIL.2015.024.
Guziejewska, B. (2016) Fiscal Illusions in Local Self-Government Finance. Complementarity of Qualitative and Quantitative Methods, Journal of US-China Public Administration, 13(7), pp. 483-489.
Guziejewska B. (2018) Normative versus positive approach to fiscal decentralisation and the measures of decentralisation. An analysis based on the example of selected countries of Central and Eastern Europe, Comparative Economic Research. Central and Eastern Europe, 21(1), pp. 101-116.
Heyndels, B. (2001) Asymmetries in the flypaper effect: empirical evidence for the Flemish municipalities, Applied Economics, 33 (10), https://doi.org/10.1080/00036840010004536.
Hines, J. R. Jr. & Thaler, R.H. (1995) Anomalies: The Flypaper Effect, The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9(4), pp. 217-226.
Feld L. P. & Schaltegger Ch. A. (2005) Voters as a Hard Budget Constraint: On the Determination of Intergovernmental Grants, Public Choice 123, p. 147-169.
Kjaergaard, I. M. (2015) The Flypaper Effect: Do Political Institutions Affect Danish Local Governments’ Response to Intergovernmental Grants?, Local Government Studies, 41(4), pp. 534-552.
Kusuma, H. (2017) Flypaper Effect: Fiscal Illusion and Bureaucratic Model, Jurnal Ekonomi dan Studi Pembangunan, 9(1), https://doi.org/10.17977/um002v9i12017p027.
Langer, S. & Korzhenevych, A. (2018) Equalization transfers and the pattern of municipal spending: An investigation of the flypaper effect in Germany, CEPIE Working Paper, No. 01/18, Technische Universität Dresden, Center of Public and International Economics (CEPIE), Dresden, available at: http://nbn-resolving.de/urn:nbn:de:bsz:14-qucosa-234984 (February 02, 2020).
Local Data Bank of Statistics Poland, available at: https://bdl.stat.gov.pl/BDL/start (April 15, 2020).
López-Laborda J. & Zabalza A. (2012) Intergovernmental Fiscal Relations: The Efficiency Effect of Taxes, Transfers and Fiscal Illusion, International Center for Public Policy Working Paper 12-29, Andrew Young School of Policy Studies, Georgia State University.
Melo, L. (2002). The Flypaper Effect under Different Institutional Contexts: The Colombian Case, Public Choice, 111(3/4), pp. 317-345, https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1014964318685.
Ministry of Finance, The Polish Ministry of Finance Information, available at: https://www.gov.pl/web/finanse/wielkosc-udzialu-gmin-we-wplywach-z-podatku-pit-w-2020-r-wyniesie-3816 (February 11, 2020)
Oulasvirta, L. (1997) Real and perceived effects of changing the grant system from specific to general grants, Public Choice, 91, pp. 397–416, https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1004987824891.
Poniatowicz, M., Dziemianowicz, R., & Alińska A. (2016) Limited Taxing Power of Local Government Entities in Poland as a Determinant of Tax Competition at the Local Level, International Journal of Economics, Commerce and Management (IJECM), 4(3), available at: http://www.ijecm.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/437.pdf (July 22, 2020).
RIO (Regional Accounting Chambers) Sprawozdanie z działalności regionalnych izb obrachunkowych i wykonania budżetu przez jednostki samorządu terytorialnego w 2018 r., Warsaw 2019, available at: http://www.rio.gov.pl/modules.php?op=modload&name=HTML&file=index&page=spr_sejm_2018 (February 11. 2020)
Rosen, H.S. (1999) Public Finance, Fifth Edition, (New York: McGraw-Hill/Irwin).
Sang Soo, L. (2013) Asymmetry in the Flypaper Effect of the Conditional Grants: A Case of Korea, International Proceedings of Economics Development and Research, available at: http://www.ipedr.com/vol61/015-ICEFR2013-M10012.pdf, DOI: 10.7763/IPEDR. 2013. V61.15 (February 03, 2020).
Schneider, M., & Byung Moon Ji. (1987) The Flypaper Effect and Competition in the Local Market for Public Goods, Public Choice, 54(1), pp. 27-39, available at: http://www.jstor.org/stable/30024767 (November 02, 2020).
Scott, A. D. (1952) The Evaluation of Federal Grants, Economica, 19(76), pp. 377-394.
Stiglitz, J. E. (2000) Economics of the Public Sector (New York: W.W. Norton and Company).
Strumph K.S. (1998) A predictive Index for the Flypaper Effect, Journal of Public Economics, 69(3), pp. 389-412.
Torres-Reyna, O. (2007) Panel Data Analysis. Fixed & Random Effects (using STATA 10.x), Princeton University, available at: http://dss.princeton.edu/training/Panel101.pdf (July 02, 2020).
Tovmo, P. & Falch T. (2002) The flypaper effect and political strength, Economics of Governance, 3, pp. 153-177, https://doi.org/10.1007/s101010100036. (February 11, 2020).
Veiga, L. G. & Pinho, M. M. (2007) The political economy of intergovernmental grants: evidence from maturing democracy. Public Choice, 133, pp. 457–477.
Walsh, C. (1993) Fiscal Federalism, European Economy. Reports and Studies No. 5.
Wooldridge, J.M. (2010) Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and Panel Data, (Cambridge: MIT Press).
Worthington, A. & Dollery, B. (1999) Fiscal illusion and the Australian local government grants process: How sticky is the flypaper effect?, Public Choice, 99(1-2), pp. 1-14.
