Leading the Locality: Icelandic Local Government Leadership Dilemma

  • Eva Marín Hlynsdóttir University of Iceland, Faculty of Political Science, Sæmundargata 2, 101 Reykjavík, Iceland
Keywords: Local government, local government leadership, executive mayors,

Abstract

In Iceland there is a growing scepticism towards mayors with executive powers (Kristinsson 2014). At the same time there is also a substantial demand of a responsive, community orientated local leader with strong direct access into central government level. In Iceland, mayors are recruited largely through two processes: through hiring following nationwide job postings (manager-mayors) and through political appointment from within the municipal council (political mayors). This paper explores the dilemma these different role expectations create for local leaders and local leadership on the whole and how democratic renewal may both contributes to the creation as well as solving of this dilemma. Firstly, the paper discusses the foundation for growing criticism towards executive mayors and the counteractions that have been undertaken. Secondly it delves into the foundation of local leadership and looks into what local leaders believe is expected or even demanded of them by citizens, central government or local agencies in the context of democratic renewal. The findings suggest that professional management plays a vital role in democratic renewal at the local level. However, manager-mayors are expected by citizens, central government and to some part the media to behave in similar ways as political mayors. This creates a dilemma as they are expected to be neutral professionals and community oriented “political” leaders at the same time. Finally, the strong emphasis on community role and direct access of local politicians into central government makes the Icelandic mayoral system more compatible to more southern typologies than the northern typology it is usually assigned to?

Author Biography

Eva Marín Hlynsdóttir, University of Iceland, Faculty of Political Science, Sæmundargata 2, 101 Reykjavík, Iceland
Assistant Professor

References

Árnason, V., Salvör, N. & Ástgeirsdóttir, K. (2010) Siðferði og starfshættir í tengslum við fall bankanna 2008. In Rannsóknarnefnd Alþingis (ed.) Rannsóknarskýrsla Alþingis, 8 bindi (Reykjavík: Rannsóknarnefnd Alþingis).
Bäck, H., Magnier, A. & Heinelt, H. (2006) Introduction, In: Bäck, H., Magnier, A. & Heinelt, H. (eds.) The European Mayor: Political Leaders in the Changing Context of Local Democracy (Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften), pp. 7-20.
Berg, R. (2006) Political Complexity or Managerial Simplicity? Mayoral Norms of Organisational Leadership, In: Bäck, H., Heinelt, H. & Magnier, A. (eds.) The European Mayor: Political Leaders in the Changing Context of Local Democracy (Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften), pp. 311–334.
Bergström, T., Gianoli, A. & Rao, N. (2012) Strong Leadership and Local Democracy: Rivals or Potential Allies?, In: Schaap, L. & Daemen, H. (eds.) Renewal in European Local Democracies: Puzzles, Dilemmas and Options (Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften), pp. 119–143.
Bogner, A., Littig, B. & Menz, W. (2009) Interviewing Experts (London: Palgrave Macmillan).
Borraz, O. & John, P. (2004) The Transformation of Urban Political Leadership in Western Europe, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 28, pp. 107–120.
Copus, C. (2011) Elected Mayors in English Local Government: Mayoral Leadership and Creating a new Political Dynamic, Lex Localis-Journal of Local Self-Government, 9(4), 335–351, doi:10.4335/9.4.335-351(2011).
Demir, T. (2009) Politics and Administration: Three Schools, Three Approaches, and Three Suggestions, Administrative Theory & Praxis, 31(4), pp. 503–532.
Demir, T. & Nyhan, R. C. (2008) The Politics-Administration Dichotomy: An Empirical Search for Correspondence between Theory and Practice, Public Administration Review, 68, pp. 81–96, doi:10.1111/j.1540-6210.2007.00839.x.
Demir, T. & Reddick; C. G. (2012) Understanding Shared Roles in Policy and Administration: An Empirical Study of Council-Manager Relations, Public Administration Review, 72(4), pp. 526–536.
Ejersbo, N. & Svara, J. H. (2012) Bureaucracy and Democracy in Local Government, In: Mossberger, K., Clarke, S. E. & John, P. (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Urban politics (Oxford: Oxford University Press), pp. 152–178.
Eythórsson, G. T. (2012) Reinforcing the municipal level in Iceland: Ideas, policies and implementations, Icelandic Review of Politics & Administration, 8(2), pp. 431–450, doi: 10.13177/irpa.a.2012.8.2.12.
Eythórsson, G. T. (2014) Sameining sveitarfélaga á Íslandi í 70 ár. Röksemdir sameiningarsinna og andstæðinga, Icelandic Review of Politics & Administration, 10(1), pp. 143–68.
Fenwick, J., Elcock, H. & McMillan, J. (2006) Leadership and Management in UK Local Government: A Role for Elected Mayors?, International Review of Administrative Sciences, 72(3), pp. 431–447.
Fox, C. J. (1992) What do We Mean When We Say ‘Professionalism?’ A Language Usage Analysis for Public Administration, Rationality and Society, 22(1), pp. 1–17.
Gläser, J. & Laudel, G. (2010) Experteninterviews und Qualitative Inhaltsanalyse. 4th ed. (Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften).
Goldsmith, M. & Larsen, H. O. (2004) Local Political Leadership: Nordic Style, International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 28(1), pp. 121–133.
Guérin, É. & Kerrouche, E. (2008) From Amateurs to Professionals: The Changing Face of Local Elected Representatives in Europe, Local Government Studies, 34(2), pp. 179–201.
Heinelt, H. & Hlepas, N. K. (2006) Typologies of Local Government Systems, In: Bäck, H., Heinelt, H. & Magnier, A. (eds.) The European Mayor: Political Leaders in the Changing Context of Local Democracy (Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften), pp. 21–42.
Hesse, J. J. & Sharpe, L. J. (1991) Local Government in International Perspective: Some Comparative Observations, In: Hesse, J. J. (ed.) Local Government and Urban Affairs in International Perspective: Analysis of Twenty Western Industrialised Countries, (Baden-Baden: Nomos Verlagsgesellschaft), pp. 603–621.
Hlynsdóttir, E. M. (2012) Nýskipan í ríkisrekstri: Þjónustusamningar hins opinbera og réttarstaða notenda þjónustu, Icelandic Review of Politics & Administration, 8(1), 133–152.
Hlynsdóttir, E. M. (2015) Ordførermakt eller rådmannsmakt: Lokalpolitisk lederskap på Island, In: Aarsæther, N. & Mikalsen, N. H. (eds.) Lokalpolitisk lederskap i Norden (Oslo: Gyldendal Akademisk), pp. 69–87.
Hood, C. (1991) A public Management for All Seasons?, Public Administration, 69(1), pp. 3–19.
Kane, J. (2007) The Problem of Politics: Public Governance and Leadership, In: Koch, R. & Dixon, J. (eds.) Public Governance and Leadership: Political and Managerial Problems in Making Public Governance Changes the Driver of ReConstituting Leadership (Wiesbaden: Deutscher Universitets-Verlag), pp. 131–149.
Kristinsson, G. H. (2001) Staðbundin stjórnmál: Markmið og árangur sveitarfélaga (Reykjavík: Háskólaútgáfan).
Kristinsson, G. H. (2014) Hin mörgu andlit lýðræðis: Þátttaka og vald á sveitarstjórnarstiginu (Reykjavík: Háskólaútgáfan).
Kristinsson, G. H. (2015) Political Control and Perceptions of Corruption in Icelandic Local Government, Icelandic Review of Politics & Administration, 11(1), pp. 1–18.
Kristmundsson, O. H. (2003) Reinventing Government in Iceland: A Case Study of Public Management Reform (Reykjavík: Háskólaútgáfan).
Kübler, D. & Pascal, M. (2006) Mayors in Vertical Power Relations, In: Bäck, H., Heinelt, H. & Magnier, A. (eds.) The European Mayor: Political Leaders in the Changing Context of Local Democracy (Wiesbaden: VS Verlag für Sozialwissenschaften), pp. 221–244.
Kuckartz, U. (2014) Qualitative Text Analysis: A Guide to Methods, Practice and Using Software (London: Sage Publications).
Larsen, H. O. (2005) Transforming Political Leadership: Models, Trends and Reforms, In: Rikke, B. & Nirmala, R. (ed.) Transforming Local Political Leadership (London: Palgrave Macmillan), pp. 195–211.
Leach, S. & Lowndes, V. (2007) Of Roles and Rules: Analysing the Changing Relationship between Political Leaders and Chief Executives in Local Government, Public Policy and Administration, 22(2), pp. 183–200, doi:10.1177/0952076707075892.
Leach, S. & Wilson, D. (2000) Local Political Leadership (London: Policy Press).
Lidström, A. (2003) Kommunsystem i Europa (Malmö: Liber).
Littig, B. (2009) Interviewing the Elite-Interviewing experts: Is There a Difference?, In: Bogner, A., Littig, B. & Menz, W. (eds.) Interviewing Experts (New York: Palgrave Macmillan), pp. 98–116.
Mayring, P. (2000) Qualitative Content Analysis, Forum: Qualitativer Sozialforschung 1 (2), available at: http://www.qualitative-research.net (July 20, 2016).
Meier, K. J. & Hill; G. C. (2005) Bureaucracy in the Twenty-First Century, In: Ferlie, E., Lynn, L. L. Jr. & Pollitt, C. (eds.) The Oxford Handbook of Public Management, (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 51–71.
Mouritzen, P. E. & Svara, J. H. (2002) Leadership at the Apex: Politicians and Administrators in Western Local Governments (Pittsburgh: Pittsburgh University Press).
Odendahl, T. & Shaw, E. M. (2002) Interviewing Elites, In: Gubrium, J. F. & Holstein, J. A. (eds.) Handbook of Interview Research: Context and Methodology (Thousand Oaks: Sage Publications), pp. 299–316.
Osborne, D. & Gaebler, T. (1993) Reinventing Government: How the Entrepreneurial Spirit is Transforming the Public Sector (New York: Plume).
Page, E. C. & Goldsmith, M. (1987) Central and Local Government Relations: A Comparative Analysis of West European Unitary States (London: Sage Publications).
Rose, L. E. & Ståhlberg, K. (2005) The Nordic Countries: ‘Still the Promissed Land’?, In: Denters, B. & Rose, L. E. (eds.) Comparing Local Governance. Trends and Developments (London: Palgrave Macmillan), pp. 83–99.
Schreier, M. (2012) Qualitative Content Analysis in Practice (London: Sage Publications).
Schreier, M. (2014) Varianten Qualitativer Inhaltsanalyse: Ein Wegweiser im Dickicht der Begrifflichkeiten, Forum: Qualitativer Sozialforschung 15 (1), available at: http://www.qualitative-research.net (July 20, 2016).
Shefter, M. (1977) Party and patronage: Germany, Italy and England, Politics and Society, 7, pp. 403-451.
Steyvers, K., Reynaert, H., Delwit, P. & Pilet, J. B. (2009) Comparing Local Political Leadership in Transformation, In: Steyvers, K., Reynaert, H., Delwit, P. & Pilet, J.B. (eds.) Local Political Leadership in Europe: Town Chief, Cty Boss or Loco President (Brugge: Vanden Broele), pp. 9–28.

Published
2016-10-31
Section
Articles