Local Governments and Political Question Doctrine in Hungary

  • Janos Fazekas Eötvös Loránd University Budapest, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences
Keywords: local government, political question doctrine, Hungary, discretionary power, legal foundations for local self-government


The main aim of this paper is to investigate a quite unexamined area: the relationship between political question doctrine and local governments in Hungary. The research focuses on the decisions of Hungarian courts and the Constitutional Court made on this matter. The paper takes under investigation some local governmental acts which have not been reviewed by any court. The main purpose of the research is to find out whether it is possible to take local governmental acts under efficient judicial review in Hungary?


Barabás, G. (2018) Kormányzati tevékenység: a “political question doctrine” a magyar közigazgatási perjogban, In: Barabás, G., Rozsnyai, F. K. & Kovács, A. G. (eds.) Kommentár a közigazgatási perrendtartáshoz (Budapest: Wolters Kluwer Hungary), pp. 86-90.

Bradley, A. & Ewing, K. D. (2011) Constitutional and Administrative Law (15th Edition, Pearson).

Friedrich, C. (1957) Constitutional Reason of State. The Survival of the Constitutional Order (Providence: Brown University Press).

Henkin, L. (1976) Is There a "Political Question" Doctrine?, The Yale Law Journal, 85(5), pp. 597-625.

Hoffman, I. & Fazekas, J. (2018) Voluntary Municipal Tasks as Tool of The Resilience of the Local Communities (Budapest: ELTE University).

Miller, A. S. (1980) Reason of State and the Emergent Constitution of Control, Minnesota Law Review, 64, pp. 585-633.

Tushnet, M. (2002) Law and Prudence in the Law of Justiciability: The Transformation and Disappearance of the Political Question Doctrine, North Carolina Law Review, 80, pp. 1203-1235.

Warren, K. F. (2003) Administrative Discretion, In: Ravecebin, J. (ed.) Encyclopedia of Public Administration and Public Policy: A-J (Boca Raton: CRC Press), pp. 35-38.