Municipal Merger and Local Democracy: An Assessment of the Merger of Japanese Municipalities

  • Kohei Suzuki University of Gothenburg, The Quality of Government Institute
  • Hyesong Ha Yonsei University, The Center for Future Government
Keywords: municipal merger, amalgamation, legislative performance, local governemnt, Japan

Abstract

Municipal mergers have been widely used as a tool for administrative reform. The goal of most municipal mergers is to increase the efficiency of service provision, but their impact on local democracy has been neglected. In particular, little is known as to how mergers affect performance of local legislatures. In filling these gaps, this study uses a dataset of 754 Japanese city-level governments from 2008 to 2014 to examine how mergers influence legislative performance. After controlling for potential confounding factors, the analysis shows that municipal merger is negatively correlated to legislative performance.

References

Allers, M. A., & Geertsema, J. B. (2016) The effects of local government amalgamation on public spending, taxation, and service levels: evidence from 15 years of municipal consolidation, Journal of Regional Science, 56(4), pp. 659-682.

Andrews, R. (2013) Local government amalgamation and financial sustainability: the case of England and Wales, Public Finance and Management, 13(2), pp. 124- 141.

Andrews, R., & Boyne, G. A. (2009) Size, structure and administrative overheads: An empirical analysis of English local authorities, Urban Studies, 46(4), pp. 739-759.

Avellaneda, C. N., & Gomes, R. C. (2015) Is Small Beautiful? Testing the Direct and Nonlinear Effects of Size on Municipal Performance, Public Administration Review, 75(1), pp. 137-149.

Bhatti, Y., Gørtz, M., & Pedersen, L. H. (2015) The Causal Effect of Profound Organizational Change When Job Insecurity Is Low—A Quasi-experiment Analyzing Municipal Mergers, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 25(4), pp.1185-1220.

Bhatti, Y., Olsen, A. L., & Pedersen, L. H. (2011), Administrative professionals and the diffusion of innovations: The case of citizen service centres, Public Administration, 89(2), pp. 577-594.

Blom‐Hansen, J., Houlberg, K., & Serritzlew, S. (2014) Size, democracy, and the economic costs of running the political system, American Journal of Political Science, 58(4), pp. 790-803.

Boyne, G. A. (1996) Scale, performance and the new public management: an empirical analysis of local authority services, Journal of management studies, 33(6), pp. 809-826.

Cameron, A. C., & Trivedi, P. K. (2010). Microeconometrics using stata (Vol. 5) (College Station, TX: Stata press).

Carr, J. B., & Feiock, R. C. (1999) Metropolitan government and economic development, Urban Affairs Review, 34(3), pp. 476-488.

Chihō Gyōzaisei Chōsakai. (2007-2012) Zenkoku Chiji: Shichōsonchō Meibo [Profiles of Governors and Mayors in Japan].(Tokyo: Chihō Gyōzaisei Chōsakai).

Chihō Jichi Sōgō Kenkyūjo. (2007-2012) Zenkoku Shucho Meibo [List of Mayors] (Tokyo: Chihō Jichi Sōgō Kenkyūjo).

CLAIR (2013) Local Government in Japan 2012, available at: http://www.clair.or.jp/j/forum/pub/pdf/jichi12_en.pdf (November 14, 2016).

Dahl, M. S. (2011) Organizational change and employee stress, Management Science, 57(2), pp. 240-256.

Dahl, R. A., & Tufte, E. R. (1973) Size and democracy (Vol. 2) (Stanford, Calif.: Stanford University Press).

Denhardt, R. B., Denhardt, J. V., & Aristigueta, M. P. (2015) Managing human behavior in public and nonprofit organizations (Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications).

Denters, B., Goldsmith, M., Ladner, A., Mouritzen, P. E., & Rose, L. E. (2014) Size and local democracy (Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing).

Dollery, B., Byrnes, J., & Crase, L. (2007) Is bigger better? Local government amalgamation and the South Australian rising to the challenge inquiry, Economic Analysis and Policy, 37(1), pp. 1-14.

Drew, J., Kortt, M. A., & Dollery, B. (2014) Economies of scale and local government expenditure: evidence from Australia, Administration & Society, 46(6), pp. 632-653.

Ehime Prefecture (n.d.) Ehimeken Shichoson Gappei Q&A [Municipal Consolidation in Ehime Prefecture, Q&A], available at: http://www.pref.ehime.jp/h10800/gappei/faq/documents/faq_all.pdf (November 13, 2016).

Ferraz, C., & Finan, F. (2009) Motivating politicians: The impacts of monetary incentives on quality and performance, available at: http://www.nber.org/papers/w14906 (December 26, 2016).

Fitzpatrick, J., Goggin, M., Heikkila, T., Klingner, D., Machado, J., & Martell, C. (2011) A new look at comparative public administration: Trends in research and an agenda for the future, Public Administration Review, 71(6), pp. 821-830.

Fox, W. F., & Gurley-Calvez, T. (2006) Will consolidation improve sub-national governments? World Bank policy research working paper, (3913), available at: http://www1.worldbank.org/publicsector/decentralization/decentralizationcorecourse2006/OtherReadings/FoxGurley.pdf (November 14, 2016).

Fukuoka City Council Secretariat. (2015) Gikai Chousa Repouto: Giin Teian Seisaku Jourei ni tsuite [Local Council Report-Policy recommendation ordinance], available at: http://www.city.fukuoka.lg.jp/data/open/cnt/3/1374/1/tyousareport_No15.pdf (December 20, 2016).

Gendźwiłł, A., & Swianiewicz, P. (2016) Does Local Democracy Perform Better in Smaller Jurisdictions? Survey Evidence from Poland, Lex localis-Journal of Local Self-Government, 14(4), pp. 759-782.

Grissom, J. A., & Harrington, J. R. (2013) Local Legislative Professionalism, American Politics Research, 41(1), pp. 76-98.

Hansen, S. W. (2013) Polity Size and Local Political Trust: A Quasi‐experiment Using Municipal Mergers in Denmark, Scandinavian Political Studies, 36(1), pp. 43-66.

Hansen, S. W. (2015) The democratic costs of size: How increasing size affects citizen satisfaction with local government, Political studies, 63(2), pp. 373-389.

Hirose, K. & Local Council Reform Forum (2009-2014) Gikai Kaikaku Hakushi 2009-2014 [White Paper on Local Council Reform 2009-2014] (Tokyo, Japan: Seikatsusha).

Hirose, K., & Local Council Reform Forum (2014) Gikai Kaikaku Hakushi 2014 [White Paper on Local Council Reform 2014] (Tokyo, Japan: Seikatsusha).

Hirsch, W. Z. (1968) The Supply of Urban Public Services, In: Perloff, H. & Wingo, L. (eds.) Issues in Urban Economics (Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press), pp. 477–526.

Jreisat, J. E. (2005) Comparative public administration is back in, prudently, Public Administration Review, 65(2), pp. 231-242.

Kawasaki, N. (2000) Urban democracy in Japan, In: Gabriel, O., Hoffmann-Martinot, V. & Savitch, H. V. (eds.) Urban Democracy (Wiesbaden: Springer), pp. 397-429.

Kjaer, U., Hjelmar, U., & Leth Olsen, A. (2010) Municipal amalgamations and the democratic functioning of local councils: the case of the Danish 2007 structural reform, Local government studies, 36(4), pp. 569-585.

Larsen, C. A. (2002) Municipal size and democracy: a critical analysis of the argument of proximity based on the case of Denmark, Scandinavian Political Studies, 25(4), pp. 317-332.

Lassen, D. D. & Serritzlew, S. (2011) Jurisdiction size and local democracy: Evidence on internal political efficacy from large-scale municipal reform, American political science review, 105(02), pp. 238-258.

Lomax, K. (1952) A criterion of efficiency in local administration, Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series A (General), 115(4), pp. 521-523.

Meier, K. J., Rutherford, A. & Avellaneda, C. N. (eds.) (2017) Comparative Public Management: Why National, Environmental, and Organizational Context Matters: Georgetown University Press.

MIC (2014) Shichouson Suu no Hensen to Meiji Showa no Daigappei no Rokucho [Numbers of local goverments and Meiji and Showa Great Merger], available at: http://www.soumu.go.jp/gapei/gapei2.html (July 2, 2016).

MIC (2014-2015) Shichoson Betsu Kessan Joukyou Shirabe Heisei 25-26 nendo [Settlement of Municipality Finances: 2013-2014], available at:: http://www.soumu.go.jp/iken/kessan_jokyo_2.html (July 2, 2016).

MIC (2015a) Chihou Gikai Seidotou Ni Tsuite. [Local Council System], available at: http://www.soumu.go.jp/main_content/000390643.pdf (April 20, 2017).

MIC (2015b) Regional Statistics Database, available at https://www.e-stat.go.jp/regional-statistics/ssdsview/ (April 20, 2017).

MIC. (n.d.-a) Chihou Koukyou Dantai Ga Ninau Jimu. [Main affairs that are handled by local governments], available at: http://www.soumu.go.jp/main_content/000088794.pdf (July 2, 2016).

MIC (n.d.-b) Nendobetsu Gappei Kensu. [Number of Municipal Mergers], available at: http://www.soumu.go.jp/main_content/000283314.pdf (July 2, 2016).

MIC. (n.d.-c) Shichoson Gappei Shiryoshu. [Information Packet of Municipal Consolidations], available at: http://www.soumu.go.jp/gapei/gapei.html (July 2, 2016).

Miyazaki, T. (2014) Municipal consolidation and local government behavior: evidence from Japanese voting data on merger referenda, Economics of Governance, 15(4), pp. 387-410.

Mouritzen, P. E. (1989) City size and citizens' satisfaction: two competing theories revisited, European Journal of Political Research, 17(6), pp. 661-688.

Nara City Office (n.d.) Gikai Yougo Shu. [Local Council Glossary], available at: http://www.city.nara.lg.jp/www/contents/1408084920610/index.html (July 1, 2016).

Newton, K. (1982) Is small really so beautiful? Is big really so ugly? Size, effectiveness, and democracy in local government, Political studies, 30(2), pp. 190-206.

O’Toole, L. J. & Meier, K. J. (2014) Public management, context, and performance: In quest of a more general theory, Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory, 25(1), pp. 237-256.

OECD (2014) OECD Regional Outlook 2014 Regions and Cities: Where Policies and People Meet (Paris: OECD), available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.1787/9789264201415-en (November 14, 2016).

Pettigrew, A. M., Woodman, R. W. & Cameron, K. S. (2001) Studying organizational change and development: Challenges for future research, Academy of management journal, 44(4), pp. 697-713.

Pfeffer, J. & Salancik, G. R. (1978) The external control of organizations: A resource dependence perspective (New York: Harper & Row).

Raadschelders, J. C. & Lee, K. H. (2011) Trends in the study of public administration: Empirical and qualitative observations from Public Administration Review, 2000–2009, Public Administration Review, 71(1), pp. 19-33.

Reingewertz, Y. (2012). Do municipal amalgamations work? Evidence from municipalities in Israel, Journal of Urban Economics, 72(2), pp. 240-251.

Shepherd, W. G. (1990) The Economics of Industrial Organization (Englewood Cliff s, NJ: Prentice Hall).

Shipan, C. R. & Volden, C. (2006) Bottom‐up Federalism: the diffusion of antismoking policies from US cities to states, American Journal of Political Science, 50(4), pp. 825-843.

Steiner, R. & Kaiser, C. (2017) Effects of amalgamations: evidence from Swiss municipalities, Public Management Review, 19(2), pp. 232-252.

Stigler, G. J. (1958) The Economies of Scale, Journal of Law and Economics, 1, pp. 54-71.

Suzuki, K. (2016) Politics of Municipal Consolidation, In: Farazmand, A. (ed.) Global Encyclopedia of Public Administration, Public Policy, and Governance (Cham: Springer International Publishing), pp. 1-7.

Suzuki, K. & Sakuwa, K. (2016) Impact of municipal mergers on local population growth: an assessment of the merger of Japanese municipalities, Asia Pacific Journal of Public Administration, 38(4), pp. 223-238.

Takagishi, Y., Sakata, M. & Kitamura, T. (2012) Influence of the Municipal Merger on Local Government Employees’ Stress Response in Japan, Industrial health, 50(2), pp. 132-141.

Vojnovic, I. (2000) The transitional impacts of municipal consolidations, Journal of Urban Affairs, 22(4), pp. 385-417.

Whetten, D. A. (1978) Coping with incompatible expectations: An integrated view of role conflict, Administrative Science Quarterly, 23(2), pp. 254-271.

Yamada, K. (2018) From a Majority to a Minority How Municipal Mergers in Japan Changed the Distribution of Political Powers and the Allocation of Public Services Within a Merged Municipality, Urban Affairs Review, 54(3), pp. 560-592.

Yokomichi, K. (2007) The development of municipal mergers in Japan, available at: http://www.jlgc.org.uk/en/pdfs/up-to-date_en1.pdf (November 10, 2016).

Yoon, J. B. & Jeong, H. O. (2016) Developing a measure of legislative professionalism for local assemblies in South Korea, Philippine Political Science Journal, 37(1), pp. 26-42.

Published
2018-10-23
Section
Articles